You can learn more about your AI visibility in an hour with a spreadsheet than with most dashboards — if you track the right things consistently. Here's the process we use.
Write 10–20 questions your buyers actually ask, phrased the way they'd ask an assistant. Include comparison questions ("best X for Y"), problem questions ("how do I..."), and brand questions ("what do people say about [category]"). Keep the wording fixed — you're measuring change over time, so consistency matters more than cleverness. Need ideas? The free audit tool will generate a starter set for your brand.
Use the ones your audience uses: typically ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews. Add Claude or Copilot if relevant. Check the same prompts in each engine on the same day.
For each prompt and engine, record:
Run each prompt two or three times and note variation — AI answers are not deterministic, and a single run is a weak signal.
After three or four weekly runs, patterns emerge: prompts where you're consistently absent, sources that keep appearing, competitors who show up often. Those are your priorities. For how to interpret each pattern, see step 4 of the audit checklist.
Manual tracking gets painful with many prompts, daily cadence, several engines or client reporting. That's the point to compare software. Our tool comparison groups options by agency, in-house and content-team use cases. Understand the underlying metrics first in the citation explainer.